Andrew
Hello there, I'm Dr. Andrew Frankel, consultant nephrologist at Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust.
Jeremy
And hello, I'm Jeremy Levy, also a consultant nephrologist at Imperial NHS Trust. And welcome to another episode of For Kidneys Sake, that fantastic podcast, All Things Kidneys. And today we thought we'd talk a bit about diuretics and chronic kidney disease, because this seems to cause huge misconceptions and confusion. And we get a lot of phone calls and emails about diuretics, when to use them, when to stop them in patients with chronic kidney disease, mostly seeming very confused.
Andrew
You're absolutely right, and I know that we often see in our primary care or our acute services patients who were getting these important medicines, having them stopped, which then makes them in fact more unwell with increasing breathlessness or increasing edema, for example. We see the patients on the wrong diuretic dose when they have CKD. And finally, we know there are lots of concerns that the diuretics may be causing or worsening kidney disease.
So altogether it's an area of uncertainty, particularly in primary care, which I hope that we can clarify a little bit more about in the next fifteen minutes.
Jeremy
Yeah, clarify, Andrew, and not cause confusion. That's our aim, isn't it? So, I'm going to kick off with a really important fact. But fundamentally, diuretics do not cause kidney failure or chronic kidney disease, or only extremely rarely. And they're not associated overall with the worsening or progression of chronic kidney disease. And there are loads of studies out there showing that the most recent, actually, and one of the largest, was from California, very recently, looking at 50,000 people with GFRs between 15 and 50 mls per minute, so chronic kidney disease. And in that large cohort, neither the initiation of diuretics, nor continuation of diuretics, nor the type of diuretic was associated in any way with chronic kidney disease progression or end-stage kidney disease after accounting for their underlying disease and their comorbidities. the diuretics were not the cause of any problems in a very large pool of people with chronic kidney disease.
Andrew
That's a pretty strong start, Jeremy, and pleased you've highlighted that and reassured people. But it is, of course, as long as these agents are used appropriately. And Jeremy, I'm sure you'd agree that if used incorrectly, they can cause deterioration in kidney function simply by causing volume depletion. And that is often the fear that many primary care clinicians have when they start these medicines. And that paranoia is perhaps reinforced by the fact that we do know that if the patient starts a diuretic, their GFR often falls a bit, doesn't it, as their circulating volume changes.
Jeremy
That's exactly right, Andrew. Both the bits of that sentence you just said. Sure, the patient's decreases too much, then of course they essentially get dehydrated. And a small drop is what we're trying to achieve, is their volume overloaded patients. So that's right, diuretic use in patients who are volume depleted is inappropriate and that can cause significant acute kidney injury, a kidney problem. But not when the patient's volume overloaded and we're trying to get them back down to the right volume. And in that setting, small drops in GFR are often seen and are not a problem.
Andrew
Okay Jeremy, so let's move on for primary care. What are we using them for in patients with CKD? Why would a primary care clinician prescribe a diuretic in a person with CKD?
Jeremy
Well, there are three reasons, there Andrew? So the one is treating hypertension. Secondly, it might be for treating fluid overload, for example, patients with peripheral oedema or pulmonary oedema. And thirdly, because they really do facilitate the action of angiotensin blockers, both for managing heart failure, chronic kidney disease and hypertension. So I'm sure everybody listening to this will know full well that diuretics are very effective drugs for treating hypertension in anyone.
They've been around for a very long time, loads of trials showing they are effective antihypertensive agents. And these are the thiazide diuretics, which are predominantly indapamide, bendroflumethiazide and chlorphthalidone. And these have been used for almost 50 years and they're clearly effective in the general population for treating hypertension. They make patients excrete more sodium and that's essentially the mechanism of action, though it's much more complicated.
But they do also cause sometimes low potassiums and low magnesium. So they need checking at times. But they're also very effective at facilitating angiotensin blockade in managing hypertension. So the combination of those two are much more potent than either alone in treating hypertension. So hypertension itself, they're very effective. And interestingly, Chlorthalidone, which is much less used in the UK, has the longest half-life and some of the best evidence for treating blood pressure, but here it's used much less than, for example, Indapamide or Benzoyl Fluoride, but it also has the highest risk of hypokalemia. So that's why people would be very familiar with diuretics out there in the general population.
Andrew
Okay, Jeremy, myth busting. Weren't we always taught that thiazides don't work in CKD?
Jeremy
We were, Andrew. It was long said that no point using them if your GFR is low, they won't work. Long story short, that turns out to be wrong. In fact, very recently, a very good large randomised control trial using Chlorthalidone in patients with CKD stage G4, so that's GFRs between 15 and 30, showed very good efficacy in resistant hypertension when added as another agent. So, thiazides for hypertension do work in chronic kidney disease.
Andrew
So there is a really important message for primary care is where you feel you need to use a thiazide to augment blood pressure control, you can do so even down to an EGFR of 20. And I would add, and this relates to one of our recent podcasts on potassium, that thiazides are actually very caloric as you pointed out, Chlorthalidone has a great tendency to cause hypokalemia, and that's potentially another benefit in these patients with CKD.
So that's our brief array into hypertension and diuretics. You then mentioned fluid retention in CKD Jeremy.
Jeremy
Well, that's right. So very many patients with particularly more advanced chronic kidney disease, as they lose nephrons, they can no longer excrete a sodium load that they need to. There's a lot of sodium in our diets and that leads to sodium retention, which essentially leads to fluid retention. Again, not quite so straightforward, but fundamentally failure to excrete sodium as you lose nephrons, sodium retention leading to fluid retention. And that then leads to ascites. Oedema, pulmonary oedema, leg swelling are what patients complain about. So advancing chronic kidney disease and fluid retention are intertwined in very many patients, not all, but very many. And then the fluid retention also drives hypertension. But not just that, actually. Fluid retention throughout the body tends to increase inflammation. Patients who are fluid overloaded have more hospitalisation and worse cardiovascular morbidity and mortality.
And course that's one of the reasons why we're recommending salt restriction in all people with chronic kidney disease. Not just to manage blood pressure, but also to avoid fluid retention. But this is why also diuretics can be really useful. If that's the problem, sodium retention, fluid retention, using diuretics which might allow you to excrete more sodium will be very helpful. And you've already mentioned the fact that you might lose some potassium can be really helpful if people have got difficult to control blood potassium levels as well.
Andrew
So just thinking about that issue of fluid retention, we talked about thiazides working in CKD for hypertension, but I note that we tend to use loop diuretics. We reach for the loop diuretics a lot when we're trying to get rid of fluid. What's the difference in people with CKD between thiazides and loop diuretics when you're looking at fluid retention?
What's the advice you would give in terms of using one form of diuretic over another?
Jeremy
Of course, the major loop diuretic we'll come to in a moment that most people will be familiar with is furosemide, so you're right, Andrew, you're absolutely right. Undoubtedly, loop diuretics are much more potent than thiazides at getting rid of sodium and therefore relieving sodium and water retention, especially in patients with chronic kidney disease. They're more bioavailable in CKD. They're more potent as your GFR declines. So they are definitely for fluid retention much more effective than far side diuretics in chronic kidney disease.
Andrew
So I know that Furosemide, as you said, is the one that seems to be the most popular, but I understand that both Torasemide and Bumetanide may be more potent. Is that right?
Jeremy
You're always right, Andrew. Yes, of course that's right.
Andrew
Of course, of course, I know. But I need reassurance, Jeremy.
Jeremy
I'm an insecure young man that you are. So, I'll tell you again, you were right. So, Torasemide is more potent than Flutamide but really rarely used in the UK. It seems to be widely used across Europe but rarely in the UK. It has a longer mechanism of action, it's better absorbed. So, it is slightly more potent. And Bumetanide, which actually is used in the UK quite a lot, is even more potent. It is better absorbed when you've got gut edema, which actually is quite common in people with fluid overload.
It's more potent and it has a slightly longer duration of action. So it is more potent than Furosemide But familiarity has led to Furosemide still being used initially by most people and especially in primary care. And actually a sequence might be to start Furosemide and in the UK move to Bumetanide when Furosemide is not effective. But some other things to say about these groups. So Furosemide is effective. I said not quite as potent as Bumetanide but it has a very short half-life and I think people forget that. They use it as a once-a-day drug but actually the effect has worn off within a few hours and that paradoxically leads to a problem very well described where actually you get a rebound increased sodium reabsorption in the hours later and that's because of effects on the distal tubule. So using Fruzamide once a day patients will of course say they pee more and more for a few hours, but actually they might retain sodium later on in the afternoon. So we should ideally in the setting of CKD and fluid retention really be using Furosemide twice a day, but don't give it at nighttime so patients are gonna be peeing while they're trying to sleep. But a morning dose and a lunchtime dose means they've got profound inhibition of sodium channels so they excrete more sodium throughout the day. And that can be really important and really effective use of Furosemide.
Andrew
Jeremy, I love the fact that I do these podcasts with you, and despite my age, I still learn new practical facts. So for fluid retention in CKD, Furosemide or Bumetanide but consider using the twice daily dosage of frusomide. So the other issue is what about the actual dose? Perhaps we need to tell primary care little bit more about what dose you start and what dose you can go up to in people with chronic kidney disease.
Jeremy
Yeah, another very important point, Andrew. So the sort of standard dose of the tablet size essentially is sort of 40 milligrams of Furosemide in general. But we often see patients started in primary care on 20 milligrams because GPs or prescribers are worried of giving a diuretic in a patient with CKD. But if you've decided you need it because they're fluid overloaded, then you need to give a dose that's going to work.
And of course paradoxically, or not paradoxically because there's a kidney problem, you actually need higher doses of Furosemide, not lower doses, because you've got to get the Furosemide through the glomerular into the tubular fluid to actually act on the sodium channels. So starting low is just wasting money, wasting drug, and patients will see no benefit. So in chronic kidney disease, do not start Furosemide at low doses, 20 milligrams. In general, 40mg might be a starting dose and as I've said very often 40mg twice a day but if they're really not responding to 40mg go up quite quickly to higher doses. So let's say it was going to be 40mg once a day then try twice a day then 80mg twice a day but actually we are very comfortable using up to 160mg twice a day of Furosemide particularly in an advanced chronic kidney disease. Sounds like a huge dose.
But it's actually trying to get this drug into the kidney tubules where it's effective. And once you've got CKD, that requires high oral doses. So don't go giving 20 milligrams. Start at 40, but rapidly increasing. So maximum really in primary care would be 160 milligrams of Prusamide twice a day. And if you're at that sort of doses, actually, I think you might be thinking about switching to one of these more potent diuretics.
Andrew
So we're we're bordering on the realm not just of CKD of course but heart failure where these drugs are used. And what you've described is we're increasing the dose, but what you sometimes see in CKD, and particularly if it's in conjunction with heart failure, is that they're on eighty milligrams twice daily of Furosemide or pr two milligrams twice daily of Bumetanide, and their weight isn't budging and they still have edema. So they have
Resistance to the diuretic. What's the next step, Jeremy?
Jeremy
Yeah, diuretic resistance is again very common again in more advanced CKD. So you've tried these doses, particularly, let's say, Furosemide 80 milligrams twice a day. And as you say, still patients still got peripheral edema or even ascites or still short of breath and they haven't noticed any change. Well, firstly, do reinforce a low sodium diet. And this is mostly, of course, about avoiding processed foods, which are very rich in sodium, more than freshly cooked foods. But if you're still eating bucket loads of sodium, you're not going to be to get rid of it. So reinforce a low sodium diet. And then if they're on Furosemide, that's switched to Bumethanide. Bumethanide is more potent. One milligram of Bumethanide is essentially equivalent to 40 milligrams of Furosemide, but more effective essentially, and can also be used twice a day for the same reasons I mentioned earlier. So if they were on 80, twice a day of Furosemide, switched to two milligrams of Bumethanide twice a day.
And then you can go up actually to three or even five milligrams of Bumetanide. So step number one, reinforce sodium restriction or low sodium diet. Step number two, switch Furosemide to Bumetanide. If that's not working, the next step is to combine a thiazide and a loop together because that's really potent because it blocks sodium absorption essentially throughout the tube, your proximal and distally. That's really good combination. It's very potent.
And you can use any thiazide diuretic. That can be Benzoyl Fluoride or Chlorothalidone. Although there's an obsession out there with using this drug called Metolazone, which has historic reasons. But essentially it's just a loop diuretic. And the problem with Metolazone is most pharmacists don't stock it. So you prescribe it and patients actually don't get it. Whereas the others are all available. So any thiazide in combination with the loop is a really potent diuretic combination in resistant patients.
And the last tip about that combination is patients should use the thiazide first about half an hour before the loop because you're blocking sodium reabsorption earlier in the tubule and actually getting it to work makes a big difference. So thiazide taken first thing in the morning, half an hour later your Bumetanide, that's a potent combination.
Andrew
Yes, that's a very potent combination. And we need to remind the audience that if patients are put on both, they'll need regular monitoring of their electrolytes, such as potassium and magnesium, probably every week while they are diuresing. And they'll also need monitoring of their kidney function and their weight to make sure that they don't overshoot.
Jeremy
That's really important
Andrew, no no no you're absolutely right there and that's the critical thing. Regular monitoring if people need such potent diuretics.
Andrew
And it's that overshooting that then will cause changes in GFR because of volume repletion. So they've got to be monitored for their weight. and if you do overshoot, then you see the creatinine rising and the GFR falling.
Jeremy
That's right, Andrew. And that's the really critical thing. So that if you kept going with the diuretics, once the patients already volume depleted, they've lost their oedema, that's when you run into essentially the problem of crack cratin rising fast because you've then got a patient with under perfused kidneys. But early on, when you're using the diuretics to slowly reduce the volume, the crating does go up a little bit and the GFR will fall a little bit. But that's to be expected. And it can be up to about 30 percent.
Drop in GFR. So that in itself is not a problem, but it does need ongoing monitoring. Is the weight going down? Are they losing their oedema? And then further checks. As you say, it might initially be weekly, then as they get better, less often. And the reason that GFR falls a bit early is that the kidney gets decongested essentially, and that's not tubular injury, but it needs careful monitoring.
Andrew
So you can see this overshoot with combination therapy, but you can also see it if you're using effectively single dose loop diuretics. And as we've said, you've got to monitor the patients. You're looking to see when the patient's edema has settled, when they're lying flat, and at that point we need to step back a little bit, reduce the dose. And this is, as I said, not just in.
Chronic kidney disease, but is the practice in heart failure, and of course, when you have the two together. So you decongest them, which is really good, it has physiological benefits, but you try not to overshoot. And it's one other message I think which is important here, which I know my heart failure colleagues utilize as well, which is you need to start thinking that the dose of diuretics may not be a permanent fixed.
Dose and that you may need to adjust the dose depending on weight and weight changes in people who are prone to fluid retention. So I may tell a patient that they're able to take anything between 1 and 3 milligrams of bumetinide a day depending on changes in their weight. I suppose, Jeremy, we also ought to mention some of the side effects of these drugs just to make sure we compare. Complete the story.
Jeremy
Yeah, yeah, yeah, of course. We've touched on some things already, Andrew, haven't we? So there is a need to monitor electrolytes. So depending on quite what you're using, if it's just 40 milligrams, it proves my problem is much less common. But if you're needing more potent doses or combinations, so regular monitoring of sodium, potassium, kidney function, magnesium, if they're on potent diuretics as well, because you can lose magnesium. And the frequency of blood testing will depend on what doses you're needing, whether it's acute, whether it's chronic and whether it's combination.
Thiazides can cause low sodium, doesn't occur with loop diuretics, so that needs monitoring as well. And all the diuretics can of course contribute to gout or rising uric acid levels. So clearly patients with a predisposition to gout have a problem. But sometimes these things do go hand in hand and you just have to use diuretics because they're volume overloaded, in which case managing the gout is a separate issue.
Andrew
Jeremy, this has been a really great discussion. You've given me a lot to think about and a lot of practical tips about using diuretics. Now I'm going to cheat as I always do when it's my turn to give the three takeaways, but my messages are: combining diuretics with other antihypertensive drugs together with sodium restriction is the key to optimise blood pressure when patients have difficult hypertension, particularly in CKD. And
That thiazides do work in CKD. Don't be frightened to use the higher dose of diuretics in people with lower GFRs, and using Furosemide twice daily can be much more effective. Bumetamide itself is more effective as a diuretic. Adding a thiazide to a loop diuretic is very helpful for stubborn resistant fluid retention.
And finally do monitor electrolytes, accept a modest creatinine rise during diuresis, and educate patients about monitoring rate and blood pressure and sick day guidance.
Jeremy
That was definitely cheating Andrew, you were meant to have three takeaways. That was complex sentences with about six takeaways. You failed.
Andrew
I know, I know. As always,
Jeremy
Ha ha.
Andrew
As always. There's a lot of messages there. So people may want to replay my last three takeaways and pull out the eight pieces of advice I gave them in that three sentences. so just a reminder to our audience that all our previous episodes are available wherever you are and you can get your podcast if you just go to For Kidneys Sake podcast site.
Jeremy
Great chat Andrew, bye from me.
Andrew
Bye.