Joana Teles
For Kidneys Sake makes kidney disease management easy. For Kidneys Sake is for primary care clinicians. For Kidney's Sake is nice, consistent, short and sweet. Welcome to For Kidneys Sake brought to you by Northwest London NHS Kidney Care Team.
Jeremy
So hello, I'm Jeremy Levy. I'm a consultant nephrologist, a kidney specialist at Imperial NHS Trust.
Andrew
Hello, I'm Andrew Frankel who works with Jeremy, also as a consultant kidney doctor at Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust. And welcome to another episode in our series of podcasts called For Kidney's Sake.
So in this podcast, we want to talk to you about a topic of growing importance, which is the conservative or symptom or supportive base care of people with end stage kidney failure. And also we're going to talk to you about advanced care planning in end stage kidney disease.
Basically, conservative means not undertaking dialysis when kidney function is terrible, and critical importance of this is that it's a rational and sensible approach to kidney failure, particularly in the very elderly and comorbid. I'm sure that our audience already understands advanced care planning, but for people with severe kidney failure, i.e. those with CKD stage 5 or on dialysis.
We mean planning for what people want if they become severely unwell, their kidneys fail if they're not already on dialysis, such as if they get sepsis or a severe stroke. And in order to cover these topics, we are really delighted to be joined today by Sister Ginny Prout, who has previously been a senior dialysis nurse for many years.
And is now leading work at Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, talking to patients on dialysis about what they want going forwards, about advanced care planning, and about options for stopping dialysis, as well as options for not choosing dialysis in the first place. Welcome Ginny.
Ginny
Delighted to join you both and it's so good that we're talking about this topic.
Jeremy
Ginny, I'm upset actually for you. Andrew's been rude to you already by saying you're such an experienced nurse. It made it sound like you were an old gorgon or something, which you're not. You're one of the most dynamic members of our team and it's so good to have a senior nurse who's moved from the technical aspects of dialysis to conservative care and supportive care and advanced care planning.
Andrew
It's my it's my cataracts, Jeremy, I'm sorry.
Jeremy
So, so, and we really want Ginny's talk about all of her experiences, but I'm going to set the scene and we really want GPs to know about this, not because they're ever going to be, you know, having the primary conversation about this, but because it's such a growing problem overall, and it's really important that primary care knows what we do about it and how we want to approach it. And because we've got this growing, very elderly population of people with chronic kidney disease who are approaching kidney failure, end stage kidney disease. And these people we often share care with. They see their GPs, they see primary care and they see us. So it's really important that we're all speaking the same language. And we need to emphasise this is not about rationing or restricting care or choices. This is about the rational choice for people, particularly the very elderly and the comorbid about what to do when something else is going wrong their kidneys. And we know that more and more this older group of people who are co-morbid and we're not talking about the 50 year olds and the 60 year olds, we're talking about people over 75, over 80 who develop kidney failure. The kidney number is much less important and this is all about symptoms and starting dialysis is much less important. And these people often won't live very long and we need to think about the burden that dialysis may impose on them and the burden is not just medical, it's travel, it's time, etc.
And people like this also have got declining cognition and the conversations we're going to talk about are about what people really want with their lives and it's really good for us to able to have an open conversation about what people really want to do and any active management of symptoms. So that's the sort of the background really I think to all of this Andrew isn't it?
Andrew
Yeh absolutely. And I think just to really emphasise one of your points, this is about people who are more elderly, 75 or over 80 with severe kidney failure. And we are going to see more and more of this population. It's a side effect of the success we have now in slowing progression kidney disease. So this is something that is going to become increasingly relevant to medical care both across primary and secondary care.
Jeremy
It is you're right Andrew it's a paradoxically we've got great new treatments and slow down kidney disease and it's creating another problem which is the very elderly with awful kidneys who we need to think about much more. Right enough for you and me we need to bring Ginny in here don't we? So let's Ginny start talking about this and we're going to first talk about people on dialysis even though that's actually a much smaller number and about things they may be thinking about and then after that we'll talk about people with chronic kidney disease who are thinking about choices before dialysis.
And Ginny, I know that you've now spoken to, I mean, it's several hundred patients, isn't it now, on dialysis and about planning their future, what they want, what their options are, which includes things like stopping dialysis potentially, to just tell us who are you typically seeing and how do you approach such meetings which can sound from the outside really quite challenging and really most importantly, how do patients respond?
Ginny
Thank you, Jeremy. Yes, I've seen nearly 500 patients with their families now. The teams in our dialysis units know many of our patients very well indeed, and it's often easy for them to recognise patients with worsening overall frailty, with declining tolerance of the dialysis procedure itself and with less tolerance of the other relentless stressors that accompany dialysis, such as waiting for transport, long periods of immobility. These frail patients are referred to me. And then other patients may be less frail, but have obviously worsening comorbid disease. And their need for advanced care planning is also fairly clear. But in others, decline is much more insidious and we're encouraging the nurses to use objective measures of frailty routinely, to assess patients and to use this as a trigger for advanced care planning.
Staff regularly look at clinical frailty score trends and consider whether patients are becoming more dependent or more distressed, more frequently distressed, maybe admitted more frequently or having falls. Suitable patients are invited to an appointment and they're told that they're going to meet a specialist nurse who'd like to talk to them to see whether there is any additional support in the hospital or in the community, which may be useful in view of their level of frailty.
The next of kin is contacted with the patient's permission of course and warmly invited. We don't on the whole invite them for quote unquote advanced care planning because that term invokes worry and alarm.
When we meet, I start by asking the patient if they mind if I ask them a little about their lives so that I can learn a bit about them as an individual. And I find this is an ideal icebreaker. Every patient has something they're happy to share, be it about their working life or their family setup or maybe a pressing worry, whatever. And I also make a point of telling them at the beginning that I'm not in a hurry. Within a few minutes, I almost always find the patients relaxed.
Another thing, I avoid talking to family members until I've gained the confidence of the patient because of course this meeting is with the patient primarily, the next of kin. The vast majority of patients very clearly welcome the ensuing personalised, unhurried assessment of their health and circumstances which is both structured and holistic discussions focused initially on preventing deterioration, alleviating distress, identifying their goals and sometimes modifying treatment targets and parameters.
Andrew
Ginny, what a fabulous description of how you approach this. And it's so interesting to hear that the patients are generally so supportive of having these conversations and they're not frightened or made anxious. So having approached patients, Ginny, how do you then expand the conversation? What do you talk to patients about to move this forward?
Ginny
I'm a nurse, but I'm very closely supported by a consultant geriatrician, as well as by the whole renal medical team. I assess frailty as broadly as I can, thinking about a patient's physical, functional, psychological, and social situation. And then I start to talk about how we might mitigate the mitigable and about likely trajectories.
I try to make sure the questioning is gentle and if I sense I'm causing any distress I carefully consider whether the timing or my tone or maybe the whole approach needs changing. Almost always however I find that this way in, broadly frailty support, leads to a readiness on the patient's part to think about their future.
And then I'm trying to identify the patient's wishes and preferences and fears in relation to their future treatment and care.
I am trying to identify the patient's wishes, preferences and fears in relation to their future treatment and care. I try to understand their feelings, beliefs and values and consider with them how these could influence their decisions and preferences.
Jeremy
Again, that's so interesting, but I'm going to get to the sort of nitty gritty because I'm a nitty gritty person. How do you actually talk about the bit about advanced care planning? Let's say, for example, what they might want for intensive care management, resuscitation management if they have a disabling stroke. Some of those hard concrete outcomes that might happen to.
Ginny
Yes and we have to get to these subjects during meeting, be it the first meeting or a subsequent one. But again I'm a nurse, I don't decide who's suitable for intensive care or resuscitation. But my experience means that I'm very well able to interpret the wealth of information that we hold about a dialysis patient and to liaise before and after family meetings with colleagues. In many cases it's obvious when attended CPR or an ICU admission for ventilation is extremely unlikely to result in anything except a prolonged death. Many of the patients and families I meet will have had conversations, often repeatedly, about these matters during recent admissions.
Generally when I explain to them that with their permission I would like to record their wishes and preferences and priorities on the universal care plan, a record which is easily accessible to the wider team, i.e. the primary and secondary care teams, ambulance crews and nursing care homes. They're only too pleased to have this information recorded.
Importantly, I ensure that the rationale and nuances behind decisions about CPR or other treatment escalation or indeed reductions in treatment are well understood and are acceptable to the patient onto their next of kin.
And I explain that the presence of the universal care plan means that the need for repeated similar conversations, often a stressful admission to hospital, is removed, at least theoretically.
Jeremy
Yeah. And I'm getting from all this, Ginny, that actually, contrary to what we might think, that patients really appreciate that you're approaching them as an individual and holistically and having this conversation and that you're not just thinking about the technical aspects of dialysis and dropping their blood pressure and feeling a bit itchy and that actually almost universally patients appreciate that. Is that right?
Ginny
That is what happens, Jeremy. Most of the patients I see are very frail. Many are also very elderly and they do think about dying. They do wonder if dialysis is worth the enormous effort it takes and of course the time it steals from them. They deserve to know that we'll listen to them, we'll do our best to respect their wishes and their autonomy and we will help them plan for a demise in which they maintain some control and dignity.
This may involve clear discussions about what would be inappropriate escalations in treatment, maybe revising treatment goals, maybe dovetailing carefully planned palliative care with stopping dialysis treatment. And of course, this isn't always one linear conversation. It very often requires more than one meeting.
Andrew
So Ginny, that is how you are currently working with the patients who are on dialysis and d perhaps deteriorating slowly and it's a really important piece of work. But let's now talk about a much larger group, the people not on dialysis yet, mostly those with CKD stage five, talking to them about the concept of conservative care and advanced care planning.
Jeremy
Actually Andrew, before we let Ginny talk, I know you've heard a lot from me but I'm going to just kick this one off and then we'll get to Ginny. Because again, just to remind everybody, we're talking about conversations often in the very elderly, often people over 75 years or 80 of age, people who've usually got multiple comorbidities, they're often frailer. I certainly have this conversation with almost anybody but in a 30 year old, you might well just say this is an option you shouldn't consider.
But it is useful to think about symptom-based, conservative or supportive care for actually anybody. And clearly the 30 year old, we want them to have a new kidney, a transplant. But that does mean that we all get used to having the conversation and patients don't begin to feel it's just for them. For me, I know when I'm having these conversations, I start by establishing what patients already understand. What do they know about where they're at? It's clearly critically important to know about their cognitive state and who else they want in the room that of course we're talking to the patient, with the patient, but people do often want family members or friends to be with them.
And for me, I start by explaining that there are several options when kidneys are very, very bad. And I always start by talking about conservative care first. It's not the one at the end of the queue. So, know, conservative care meaning treatment of any symptoms without needing machines or dialysis, and it can control symptoms very well in many people. And then for me, I then go and talk on about dialysis as alternatives and we'll talk about this on another episode, but not just hemodialysis, which is what most people think about, but also home-based peritoneal dialysis. And then for me, I'm often trying to talk about advanced care planning as well. know, for these frail elderly patients whose kidneys are now very bad, what might they want if they get acutely sick with pneumonia or a stroke? Often that may not be one conversation. There's a lot of information we're covering in this for me. And then again, for me, I talk about the fact that for older frail patients starting dialysis, may not add anything to the length of their life, may just add complications, may help some symptoms, but really may overall not be a benefit. But that's me, but Ginny, tell us what you think in this circumstance and how you take this forward.
Ginny
Yes, conservative kidney management is widely being presented now as a positive, desirable treatment option for these elderly co-morbid patients. There's no compelling benefit statistically of dialysis over conservative kidney management in terms of longevity or quality of life.
With dialysis, there is, statistically, an increased likelihood of dying in hospital. And very glaringly, an increased amount of time will be spent in precious, very old age, having treatments in-center, which predictably exhaust them, and often exhaust their spouse or family, if there is one. Interestingly, about a third of the patients I meet tell me firmly that they do not wish to undergo Attempted CPR.
And this is almost invariably in accordance with what has been or what would be medical advice. But I mention it because in my experience, it's very clear that a time does come when people are ready to die, albeit often very reluctantly, of course. And patients acknowledge death imminence Advanced care planning helps them and their loved ones prepare themselves in all sorts of ways.
Andrew
So Ginny, what do you think are the major challenges then in this area?
Ginny
Well, it's not always easy for us to acknowledge the imminence. I suppose staff spend the vast majority of their time focused on rescuing patients, preventing harm, encouraging patients and families to keep going. Most of the communication between secondary and primary care is in that vein. Discharge summaries frequently barely mention or don't mention advanced care planning.
But nationally, think the healthcare staff are well aware now of the value and need for use for advanced care planning. But they're pleased if someone else does it. It does take time. And I think there is a fear that one might cause distress or be misinterpreted or even litigated.
It's also become very evident that in many areas, families are not being accepted for support from community palliative care until the patient is very close to the end of life, i.e. short weeks. And this is a resource issue.
So there is a period when it's essential that their GP, the kidney team, and in our own case, the renal frailty team, work together so that communication is timely and effective. And subsequently, families will have adequate support in the community with plentiful remote or in-person contact. And as I've mentioned before, these patients will all have a universal care plan with relevant advanced care planning information and contact details, easily findable.
Jeremy
That's really helpful actually and those three particular points you mentioned there, know, that healthcare professionals want somebody else to have this conversation, not themselves. The time and resource issue and actually that sad depressing bit, the palliative care services in the community sometimes are stretched. I'm going to pick you up on another area which I perceive as being a potential problem that's conflict in families and we all sort of know it happens but in this area of thinking about conservative care, not dialyzing, advanced care planning.
Is this a thing you've picked up Ginny That Ginny it's a big issue or actually is it not such a big issue? And if it does arise how do you tackle it?
Ginny
It can happen, it's not rare. I imagine even in our own families, completely well-meaning people will have totally different, well-argued ideas about all sorts of things. Sanctity of life, the rights and wrongs of giving up or not even trying a treatment which exists, but which is perhaps never or no longer suitable.
These situations are when seeking support from the whole MDT is ideal. Inevitably, some staff find supporting conflicted families easier than others. So we might draw on the expertise and experience of kidney colleagues, as well as those in geriatrics, palliative care or counselling. And we also consult with the GPs, of course, who in many instances know the families very well and can be ideally placed to support them in decision-making alongside the renal team.
Usually consensus is achieved but it might require several meetings and involve several members of staff.
Jeremy
really helpful.
Andrew
We are now nearly at the end and this has been such a useful session. I want to ask, have you found the universal care plan we're using in London then useful? You've told the patients it's useful. Have you actually found practically it's useful?
Ginny
It's a great tool. I've been reliably informed that ambulance crews routinely look for it before arriving at someone's home. Emergency departments look for it when they're admitting patients. Community palliative care teams largely insist on the presence of a UCP before they'll accept a referral. And importantly, patients can access this themselves.
And it's turned a universal care plan not because it covers absolutely everything, but because it's universally accessible and editable by all healthcare practitioners. And as we know, finding an old note about an advanced care planning conversation years ago or months ago that's deep within the record system, it's almost impossible unless you happen to know exactly when it took place and who held it. The UCP is the answer and I think we really need to keep promoting its use.
Jeremy
Very helpful. I know I've been remiss in that, I shall improve my performance because I think you're right. It's a really good way of sharing information. Finding things in electronic records is a total nightmare nowadays. Looking for one particular thing. So I'm going to add one last note really, because I think that again you've mentioned it Ginny, but we should strongly encourage, despite sometimes resource issues, our primary care colleagues to use palliative care services for people with severe kidney failure. They're not just there for cancer and lots of patients with very bad kidneys. We're talking about GFRs 456 who are near the end of their lives. They get symptoms and palliative care teams are very good at helping managing their symptoms. And at that level, we're not worried about the kidneys. So to encourage our primary care colleagues, really doesn't matter what drugs you use as long as they're safe for renal function, meaning not going to accumulate. So for example,
If somebody's got pulmonary edema or fluid overload, give them diuretics. It doesn't matter what happens to the CHFR. We're trying to make them feel better and make their breathing feel better. And where it matters is if you've got drugs that might be really excreted. So for example, pain relief. We don't use morphine on its own because it accumulates. We much rather oxycodone or fentanyl. So, you know, use pacific air services out there. Don't worry about the effects of any medications for symptoms that might affect kidney function. Think about drugs that...
Mainly dose modification, but that's about accumulation. And finally, I think my last message from all of this is to encourage our colleagues out there not to tell older, frail people that opting for conservative care is a terrible choice because they're just going to die. It's not a terrible choice. It's very often the right choice in elderly co-morbid people because dialysis is not going to make any difference to them and only going to add burden.
That's my final three, Heppanyworth, Andrew. But you're going to have to summarise as well, aren't you?
Andrew
Yeah, well, I normally finish with my three, or one of us finished with our three, but you've actually jumped in there and given your three as well. But you know something? They are extremely useful pieces of advice. And my three takeaways, it sort of s does actually echo something that you've said. We just need to be aware that putting someone on dialysis isn't simply as just plugging them into a machine. And that in the frail elderly, this is really not straightforward. It's unlikely to extend their life and it's more likely to give them a poorer quality of life. And conservative care should really be seen as a very positive alternative. We also, my second point is that we just must not be frightened about broaching these topics, since patients actually do by and large appreciate the chance to have these conversations. And once one's done this, advanced care planning really can help people ensure that they get the management that they want.
Jeremy
Thanks Andrew, they were three good points as well. course, everybody, I hope that's been useful informative discussion. Ginny, it's been fabulous having you here. If you're listening to this, do look at our website or where you ever got listened to this podcast. Give us any ideas that you want to give us about future topics.
Ginny
Thanks, Jeremy and Andrew, and I do hope the listeners found this episode useful.
Andrew
Bye then.